Free direct download · checklist

Creative Work Review Checklist

A focused critique that identifies what to keep, revise, or remove before release.

Before you open it

What it helps with

A critique framework for detecting generic language and weak choices.

Best for
People reviewing AI-assisted creative work before sharing it.
Problem it addresses
Fluent output can mask generic language, weak choices, and missing point of view.

Find the point of view first

Ask what the piece wants its audience to notice and whether that choice could be dropped unchanged into another brief, brand, or campaign. The central idea should arrive before decorative detail.

Test the language and choices

Replace abstract praise with an observable detail, flag phrases that could describe almost any competent output, and name one direction the work deliberately did not take. Keep material disagreement or uncertainty where it changes the work.

Make a concrete revision decision

For each issue, record one of: keep, sharpen, replace, remove, or research. A “sharpen” decision needs a specific addition—not a request to “make it better.”

Keep the limits visible

This checklist cannot decide taste or originality. It makes the review conversation more precise and still requires an accountable editor or maker.

Compatibility

  • Any text editor
  • Human review required

License:CC BY 4.0. Review the license before reuse.

Changelog

1.0.0 · 2026-08-06

  • Initial human-reviewed launch release.