Free direct download · template

Model Comparison Test Sheet

A comparable record of inputs, criteria, evidence, and repair effort.

Before you open it

What it helps with

A matched-condition scoring sheet for bounded model comparisons.

Best for
People comparing model workflows for one bounded task.
Problem it addresses
Unmatched prompts and vague criteria turn model comparisons into preference claims.

Set up a fair comparison

Use one row per run and keep the prompt, account tier, enabled tools, visible model, and test date explicit. Compare bounded conditions, not vague impressions from unrelated tasks.

Record evidence with every score

For each criterion, record a 1–5 score, the evidence that supports it, repair minutes, and reviewer notes. The sheet is designed to make score disagreements inspectable rather than to create a winner by default.

Read the result cautiously

Compare the resulting rows against the task’s decision and constraints. Preserve the runs, source material, and manual interventions so another reviewer can repeat or challenge the finding.

Keep the limits visible

The sheet does not establish general model quality or predict performance on another task, account, version, or date. A human reviewer still owns the conclusion.

Compatibility

  • Any text editor
  • Human review required

License:CC BY 4.0. Review the license before reuse.

Changelog

1.0.0 · 2026-08-06

  • Initial human-reviewed launch release.