# Source-to-slide review — retained run

Executed 15 October 2026 with gpt-5.6-sol via Codex CLI in a fresh context. Entire scenario is synthetic. One output is not a reliability measurement.

## Exact input

```text
You are doing one standalone writing task. Use no tools. Return only the requested deliverable.

Create a five-slide outline for a library team deciding whether to repeat a fictional AI paperwork workshop. Each slide needs a headline and two bullets. Use only this source packet. Cite source IDs beside factual claims. Distinguish observation from recommendation.

S1 — Attendance note: Eight adults registered. Six attended the 45-minute session. No one was asked to upload real documents.
S2 — Exit cards: Five of six attendees returned a card. Four of those five wrote that they could identify one decision AI should not make. Three of those five completed the paper checklist on the fictional sample. One card was blank on both questions.
S3 — Facilitator log: The projected live AI demonstration failed because the library Wi-Fi dropped. The facilitator used a prepared fictional AI response on paper instead. The group completed a date-and-amount checking activity.
S4 — Follow-up: No later survey or behavior observation exists. The team has no evidence that attendees used the method at home or improved handling of real paperwork.

```

## Raw output

### Slide 1 — Observation: Attendance Fell Short of Registration

- Eight adults registered; six attended the 45-minute workshop. [S1]
- No attendee was asked to upload real documents. [S1]

### Slide 2 — Observation: Most Respondents Identified an AI Boundary

- Five of six attendees returned exit cards. [S2]
- Four respondents identified one decision AI should not make; one card was blank on both questions. [S2]

### Slide 3 — Observation: Checklist Completion Was Mixed

- Three of five exit-card respondents completed the paper checklist using the fictional sample. [S2]
- The group completed a date-and-amount checking activity. [S3]

### Slide 4 — Observation: The Backup Plan Preserved the Session

- The live AI demonstration failed when the library Wi-Fi dropped. [S3]
- The facilitator substituted a prepared fictional AI response on paper. [S3]

### Slide 5 — Recommendation: Repeat as a Better-Measured Pilot

- Repeat the workshop with both live and paper demonstration materials, given the documented Wi-Fi failure. [S3]
- Add later follow-up before judging real-world impact; no evidence currently shows home use or improved handling of real paperwork. [S4]
